Save on Pinterest

Here Are the Top 5 Cars You Should Buy New—and 5 You Shouldn’t

In the market for a new ride? Find out if it's worth shelling out extra bucks for a brand-new dream machine, or if you should go searching for pre-owned gold.

1 / 12
Happy beautiful couple is buying a new car at dealership. Credit card in hand.4 PM production/Shutterstock

Top 5 cars to buy new

The auto experts at iSeeCars—a site that ABC News has called “the for people in the market to buy a car”—did some comparison shopping of new and used cars and put some surprising findings in a new study. While on average a new car costs 30.2 percent more than the one-year-old used version of the same model, they found a group of vehicles that only cost a few thousand more to buy new versus used. Here are their top picks for cars worth shelling out a few thousand to nab that new-car smell. Did you know these are the most reliable cars that rarely need a mechanic?

2 / 12
BRUSSELS - JAN 18, 2019: Honda HR-V car showcased at the 97th Brussels Motor Show 2019 Autosalon.VanderWolf Images/Shutterstock

Honda HR-V

MSRP: From $21,565

Difference between new and used: $2,260

According to Car and Driver, when it comes to cargo hauling, this is the best small SUV on the market, noting, “Its ingenious second-row Magic Seat is borrowed from its corporate cousin, the subcompact Honda Fit hatchback; when folded, the seat creates class-above cargo space.”

3 / 12
FRANKFURT - SEPT 2015: BMW X1 xDrive25i presented at IAA International Motor Show on September 20, 2015 in Frankfurt, GermanyDmitry Eagle Orlov/Shutterstock


MSRP: $34,950—$36,950

Difference between new and used: $4,194

The experts at love this car, explaining, “The X1 has a turbocharged 2.0-liter engine that produces 228 horsepower and 258 pound-feet of torque. That’s near the top in power for the segment.” In terms of handling, the reviewers write that the X1 is “closer to a sport sedan than its more sluggish competitors.” Do you know what the least reliable car is in the industry? Find out here.

4 / 12
CHICAGO - February 9: The 2018 Subaru Crosstrek on display at the Chicago Auto Show media preview February 9, 2018 in Chicago, Illinois.Darren Brode/Shutterstock

Subaru Crosstrek

MSRP: $21,895 – 27,195

Difference between new and used: $2,978

For ratings, U.S. News & World Report gives the Subaru Crosstrek high grades, noting that it boasts tons of cargo space and has a very user-friendly entertainment and guidance interface. Testers summarized the driving experience owners can anticipate: “It delivers a comfortable ride, allows for light off-roading, and provides plenty of passenger and cargo space. It also feels more upscale than many rivals and offers plenty of tech features.” Learn these 34 tricks car dealers know that you don’t.

5 / 12
BANGKOK - November 28: Honda CR-V car on display at The Motor Expo 2014 on November 28, 2014 in Bangkok, Thailand.bankerwin/Shutterstock

Honda CR-V

MSRP: $25,395

Difference between new and used: $3,230

In its five-star rating, Car and Driver gushed about this vehicle: “The Honda CR-V is a triple threat: It packs a host of high-tech equipment, impressive fuel economy, and copious cargo space. As if that’s not enough, it also boasts contemporary styling and excellent road manners.” If you’re in the market for a crossover SUV, Car and Driver‘s reviewers believe you’ll have a hard time finding a better vehicle.

6 / 12
DETROIT - JANUARY 13: A Toyota Tacoma Truck on display January 13th, 2015 at the 2015 North American International Auto Show in Detroit, Michigan.Darren Brode/Shutterstock

Toyota Tacoma

MSRP: $25,700 — $42,810

Difference between new and used: $3,891

Reviewers at were happy to see that the 2019 Tacoma TRD Pro upgraded its styling features from previous models: The TRD logo on the new aluminum front skid plate and three cool colors (Super White, Midnight Black Metallic, and Voodoo Blue). In terms of handling, the 2019 Tacoma, according to, has upgraded suspension and comes standard with the Toyota Star Safety System, which includes stability and traction control, anti-lock brake system and smart-stop technology. Plus: Check out these cars that are guaranteed to last you over 250,000 miles.

7 / 12
Here you go. Horizontal cropped hot of a car dealer passing keys to a new car female ownerNestor Rizhniak/Shutterstock

Top 5 cars to buy used

In another study from, the car shopping experts found that on average, a one-year-old used car costs 23.2 percent less than its new version. And with some cars, they found price differences of over 38 percent. Here are their recommendations for five gently-used rides that deliver incredible value.

8 / 12
Auto Show , Pittsburgh, USA - 14 Feb 2019Gene J Puskar/AP/Shutterstock

Ford Expedition

MSRP: $52,130 – $79,200 (new)

Difference between new and used: $24,690

Edmunds was wowed by this machine’s size and power: “Compared to the typical three-row crossover SUV, the 2019 Ford Expedition looks like a superhero. It’s able to carry eight passengers and tow nearly as much as a full-size truck. And while it’s certainly a large vehicle, there’s very little else that can match the Expedition for outright capability.”

9 / 12
NEW YORK - APRIL 1: KIA exhibit KIA Sedona SXL at the 2015 New York International Auto Show during Press day, public show is running from April 3-12, 2015 in New York, NY.Miro Vrlik Photography/Shutterstock

Kia Sedona

MSRP: $27,980 (new)

Difference between new and used: $12,918

In the minivan game, says Car and Driver, the Kia Sedona is “a handsome and high-value player.” They gave it high grades for its safety ratings and its “kid-friendly interior with plenty of space for friends.” The Sedona is not exactly a speed machine, said the testers, but “the engine is smooth and the suspension delivers an agreeable ride.” Learn to recognize these signs that your car is about to die.

10 / 12
Usa New York Auto Show - Apr 2012Justin Lane/EPA/Shutterstock

Chevrolet Impala

MSRP: $28,020 – 36,720 (new)

Difference between new and used: $11,837

As reviewed in U.S. News & World Report, the 2019 Impala “is a well-rounded large car with solid scores.” Reviewers found its standard four-cylinder engine to be lacking—they liked optional V6. “The Impala handles with confidence and treats passengers to a relaxing ride.”

11 / 12
MIAMI BEACH, FL, USA - NOVEMBER 6, 2015: Infinity QX80 on display during the 2015 Miami International Auto Show at the Miami Beach Convention Center in downtown Miami Beach.Ed Aldridge/Shutterstock

Infiniti QX80

MSRP: $65,400–$90,100

Difference between new and used: $26,188

On, this car got two thumbs up for its stylish exterior, luxury interior, innovative safety features, and spacious second row. Reviewers, however, didn’t love the leg room in the third row and were underwhelmed by its average 16 to 17 MPG, a tradeoff for its vroom-vroom 400-horsepower, 5.6-liter V-8 engine.

12 / 12
Auto Show Ford, Detroit, USACarlos Osorio/AP/Shutterstock

Ford Fusion Hybrid

MSRP: $23,835 (new)

Difference between new and used: $9,301

The reviewers at Car and Driver found the Fusion’s Infotainment options to be “feature-heavy, intuitive, and reasonably quick to respond to user inputs.” What you save in gas money, however, you pay for with a lack of storage space. “The gas-powered Fusion holds as much cargo as most competitors, but the hybrid and plug-in hybrid models suffer mightily for their battery packs, which reside in the trunk.” Those batteries will get you an average of 42 MPG, so it could be a tradeoff well worth it, depending on your needs. Now, find out the 100 maintenance tips to extend the life of your car.

Reader's Digest
Originally Published on Reader's Digest

Joe McKinley
Dan Bova is the digital editorial director of He previously worked at Jimmy Kimmel Live, Maxim and Spy magazine. He currently writes a weekly humor column for The Journal News and USA Today.